I get the concept. I do. And I wrestle with the notion myself, as Iโm an anarchist (you and I donโt agree on a few things, lemmygrad friend).
But I donโt subscribe to the notion that not voting as a principled abstainer is a righteous actโฆI donโt think. Because I do agree, of course. The democrats are capitalist, war-mongering shitheels. They arenโt โgoodโ or just or righteous by any stretch of the imagination. They destroy the environment and will kill us if we challenge the status quo of lte stage consumer capitalism. I have no illusions about this.
But doing nothing in the face of a Republican Party that is hellbent on wiping trans people from the face of the earth, strapping us all to the whipping chair until they can establish a Christofascist nightmare in which we are all beaten into straight, white submission isโฆnot a heroic act. Because, yeah, the democrats support Israel, they are neoliberal capitalist pigs. They boost police budgets whenever they can, they take obscene amounts of money from special interests and work for them, not for us. But the republicans do all the same shit PLUS hating trans and gay people and pass laws that make it so they can lock you away for protesting and they are clearly more โbusiness friendlyโ because they can be open about it while the democrats have to do slightly less because their rhetoric and their base donโt approve like Republican voters do.
My point is, there are two terrible options. Yes, we are in agreement. And yes, electoralism is bullshit, incrementalism will get us nowhere. But hierarchy is bullshit. Capitalism is bullshit. These things will exist until some insanely devastating event upturns the way the world has run for a long time.
Not voting wonโt change these realities. VOTING wonโt change them. But all the people that are hurt by an emboldened xenophobe and vicious bigot WILL be hurt. Actual, measurable hurt. PLUS the Palestinian people youโre basing your position on will continue to be killed. Because the US supports Israel. Not the democrats or republicans, but the US.
Not voting against a party that is openly using REAL LIFE fascist methods and speech so you can maintain your perceived purity isnโt noble.
We can all hate capitalism. But weโre stuck with it right now. We can all hate electoralism. But weโre stuck with it right now. Capitalism kills way more people than the genocide currently happening in Palestine. But youโre way more involved with it than you would be in electoralism by casting one vote.
These things are truths right now. Youโd do a lot more good (or at least contribute A LOT less hurt) by abstaining from capitalism than you would abstaining from electoralism. We can all be principled. But all-or-nothing-ism that is rampant on โthe leftโ (read: in modern people with principles and humanity and half a brain) isnโt noble because it helps. Itโs perceived as noble because you can say, โpfft. I didnโt _____.โ Youโre not helping anymore but yourself.
Engage in praxis. Fight for your beliefs. But when your abstinence will be weaponized by insanely powerful and horrible people, and leveraged against minority groups, your โpurityโ is nothing but self-aggrandizement.
Not voting against anti-trans Christian fascist bigots is a huge show of privilege.