Skip Navigation
User banner
Average PFLP Enjoyer
Average PFLP Enjoyer @ fanonfan44 @lemmygrad.ml
Posts 2
Comments 4

What is your most controversial opinion in Socialist circles?

I'm talking about deeply held beliefs you have that many might disagree with here or deem to be incompatible with Marxist ideology. I'm interested because I doubt everyone here is an ideological robot who all share the same uniformity in belief

0
A reminder on Lemmygrad's stance on religion (and other contentious topics)
  • an Islamic State or a Caliphate does not mean every citizen is a Muslim - it just means that the state is governed by Quranic ideals. A basic tenet of Islam is believing the Quran to be perfect so why as a Muslim would I not want to be involved in the running of a country?

    Jews and Christian's were treated much better under the Muslim caliphates than they ever were in Europe - where Spaniards violently expelled Andalusian Muslims after the Reconquista, Caliphate's housed sizeable religious communities who were treated on equal status as Muslims outside of a small Jizya tax (which would be foregone if the Jizya collector deemed that a tax collection would put unnecessary strain on a minority family, such as a single mother looking after her children or a sick man unable to work and provide).

    There is so much more to Caliphate than "Muslims rule everyone else" - it's living life in accordance to the Sunnah of the Prophet SAW and striving for social justice and unity as emphasised in Qu'ran so many times. What other Abrahamic religion specifically condemns slavery (24:33), makes taking care of the poor a religious obligation which if not performed takes one out the fold of the religion (Zakat).

    I'm not opposed to Secularism because I believe Islam is inherently superior, or because I want to rule over minorities, I'm opposed to Secularism because it is the obligation of the Muslim to live by the equality prescribed by the Prophet SAW - to separate the government of a Muslim nation from the teachings of Islam is like cutting a people at their jugular vein. There's a reason why even the most "progressive" Muslim politicians of our time such as Imran Khan would never dare ask their people to separate themselves wholly form the Qu'ran in the political sphere

    I obviously have no issue with working with the vast majority of Socialists who are Secularists, and of course it's a rather inconsequential issue in the face of Imperialism - improving material conditions is all that matters at this rudimentary stage of multipolarity and liberation

  • A reminder on Lemmygrad's stance on religion (and other contentious topics)
  • I'm a Muslim Marxist who doesn't support Secularism in the long term because I would ultimately prefer an Islamic Worker's State

  • An encounter I had in Germany
  • just wait till the Falun Gong nutjobs get their band into your city and start playing brass instruments in the town square all day screaming about how Xi Jinping is harvesting their organs

  • Im the real Xi Jinping AMA
  • yes China is about to eliminate poverty but did you ever consider human nature

  • Is it wrong to greatly prefer expressing all political views in a borderline echo chamber such as Lemmygrad rather than ever try to engage with liberals on other platforms again?

    There are only so many more braindead, agenda-fueled smug remarks I can deal with at this point and I've lost all hope of changing most of these people. Just this evening I commented a one sentence defense of China's foreign policy on reddit only to get every single one of my comments from the past week bombarded by a guy spamming Taiwan emojis and calling me a "CCP slave girl who should go to the Xinjiang rape camps". It's tiring

    5