8mo ago

What is your opinion?

138 comments

This is a bad post. Polyamory is NOT about sex and it's NOT a fetish.
It can work extremely well and be extremely loving if done correctly. The problem is, it's not as easy as people often think it is when trying to idealize it.
Communication is extremely important in every relationship and that only multiplies when you have more than one partner.
If you have a feeling of jealousy... Talk about it...
If you don't think your partner is spending enough time with you... Talk about it...
If you aren't enjoying sex with your partner... TALK ABOUT IT!
I've been with my fiancé for almost 4 years, my bf and I are celebrating our 1 year next month, and I have a new first date next Wednesday. My fiancé has even been with their nesting partner (who is monogamous) for 8 years now.
This all happened because we have clear ground rules and boundaries as well as active communication.
I've never felt more loved than when my fiancé helped me pick out my outfit for my first date with my bf.
I love them both so tremendously and it pisses me off when people tell me that isn't possible or that all I care about is sex.
- I think there are an unfortunate number of monogamous people who decide to try polyamory to fix or hold on to a dying relationship. It's not a surprise that that often goes extremely poorly. It's not for everyone and it's not gonna fix any problems.
  I've dated a couple of people who are poly, and while I'd always been in monogamous relationships, I was open to the idea. I don't think love is a finite resource, and I'm not a jealous person at all, and it turns out, it doesn't bother me at all. I also stay well away from anyone who thrives on drama, so all involved were very honest and adult about the whole thing. I wasn't in a good headspace for any relationship at the time, so it didn't work, but I'd absolutely be willing to try it again.
  
  It's really awesome that you noticed your own needs and put those first. That's really awesome and I'm proud of you for doing so.
- My nesting partner and I do not have a sexual relationship anymore, and that's totally fine. We're still in love and enjoy spending lots of time together. Polyamory is not about sex. I have other sexual partners sometimes, and that's fine. My NP also has a girlfriend who she doesn't have sex with either, and they get along like gangbusters.
  
  Exactly! Sex is completely unrelated to the process as a whole.
  It's gross how often people think that being in love is just to have someone to fuck.
- I posed it as a question for a reason. I can say every poly relationship I have known has ended in flames, but I'm open to all opinions.
  But there is no question some people should just get divorced.
  
  I can say every poly relationship I have known has ended in flames
  I strongly dislike this trope. Most monogamous relationships also end badly. Relationships are hard.
- Mah people represent 🥹
- What if I wanna talk and they don't?
  
  As with any relationship, you can either decide it's not worth it to keep bringing up... Or if it matters a lot to you, you can break up.
  Sometimes, even with a lot of communication, the relationship just doesn't work. Not everyone is meant to be. Sometimes your needs are very different from your partner(s) needs and separation is the best way to make you both happier in the long run.

If people want to practice polyamory I suppose that's their business. I personally have known a lot of people who turned their lives upside down to be in polyamorous relationships and they generally always fall apart over jealousy. One person always ends up feeling left out usually.
If you want that and you can make it work though then more power to you!
- Also if sex is all there is holding your relationship together you are fucked
  
  Literally!
- I guarantee you know more monogamous people who have lost their relationships to jealousy.
  This isn't a polyamory issue
- I think it's different for bi people maybe, but I can say everyone i know who has done it has broken up.
  
  I had a roommate who was bi and he moved like 4 states away to be in a poly relationship with like 5 other people and he moved into their house with them and everything. I saw an update from him that they had broken up and he was moving again like 3 months after that! It honestly just sounds exhausting
  
  Me and my two boyfriends are bisexual. We have been on a long distance relationship for almost 2 years and there never was a issue with jealousy between us. We are a family. We love each other and all we want is to stay with each other.
  
  This time it’ll be different though, I swear. Your sister is like family, it’ll be fine.
- I've been poly for 5ish years now and never had an issue. I'm engaged and I also have an amazing bf. It's a lot of work but... It's amazingly worth it when it works. I love my partners so much and I'm glad they have other people around them that can make them as happy as they can be.

There is a real phenomenon where many people try polyamory before they accept that their original relationship should end, then go back to just being single or start a different monogamous relationship.
This "transitional" polyamory is often looked down on but I think it's another honest attempt to deal with the pressures and problems of expected monogamy.
- My friend did it. Initially it was because her SO became basically asexual and she was trying to make it work while also meeting her own needs, and she ended up leaving him for her polyamorous partner and they got married and have been together for ages and had a baby. Sometimes the way on is the way out I guess.
- And this is exactly why obsessive ~~polygamy~~ monogamy is actually pretty toxic when you think about it. This kind of experience could also reasonably lead back to your partner, along with a renewed sense of dedication, if such a lapse of judgement was tolerated the way basically every other misstep in a marriage or serious relationship is tolerated.
  I see couples forgive way worse shit than a bit of meaningless infidelity on a routine basis.
  
  I'm not sure what you mean by obsessive polygamy.
  Do you mean people who feel strongly about having multiple wives or husbands? People who have many previous marriages? People who obsessively collect spouses? 😄

There's also asexuality. Love your partner but don't wanna fuck 'em? Get a divorce you deviant! Because apparently sex is required for a happy marriage and if you don't have sex because you're not interested in it, then you're obviously a pervert or a prude who deserves to be unloved.
- Unless you're both asexual, or are open to the sexual one fucking around, you probably should get a divorce though
  
  Unless you're both asexual, or are open to the sexual one fucking around,
  Yeah, but then you get back to the person in OP's post telling people to get a divorce regardless. My point is that you can have a happy marriage and be poly and/or ace.
  Edit: Also, I'd think that issue would come up long before marriage and would likely be solved by that point.
- I think there is another side to that though that the non-asexual partner is probably often not very happy.
  
  Ironically this is one of those things that's easier to deal with in a poly context - your partner isn't your one and only so if they're ace and you're not, you're allowed to get those needs met elsewhere and still have a loving romantic relationship with them.
- Are you disregarding your partner's needs here?
  
  One would hope that you'd solve issues like that before getting married. Whether that means an open marriage, having a partner who's also ace, finding ways to fulfill your partners needs without having sex yourself, etc.
  You're not wrong, but I think most married couples that involve someone who's ace would have that problem solved by the time they get to marriage.
  
  Why isn’t the partner doing the same in that situation?

I have nothing against practical monogamy save for this. You must free the ones you love before they can freely choose you.
It’s why insisting on lifetime guarantees of sole-possession is the worst possible way to soothe your jealousy or fear of abandonment.
If you can’t let go of that fear long enough to put someone else’s happiness first, it doesn’t matter how many oaths, contracts or incentives you use to fortify your conquest. You will never know what real trust feels like.
- (Pre-edit: this became much longer than intended. You struck a chord in me it seems.)
  You've articulated this so very well. It's a lesson that took me many years to learn and comes with the prerequisite of respecting yourself and respecting your partner to such a degree that the relationship comes second for both of you. Each person's first priority should be themselves. Both parties need to respect that to the point of accepting that staying together is not a given and is contingent on both parties being fully satisfied with the direction your lives together is heading.
  The funny thing is that I've never felt more confident in my relationship since learning that. I used to think that's putting the relationship second to yourself is antithetical to commitment but actually it's the other way around. The only way to fully commit to a relationship is to make sure that maintaining it is a concious choice rather than an expectation or given.
  The way my dad illustrated this lesson in my youth (and I took the advice but only recently learned the full meaning of it) is like this: life is a journey down a road with many crossroads. Should you find a partner, you walk together. If you hit a crossroad and can't agree on a direction then thank each other for the lovely journey together but let them follow their own path. Find that partner that is going to the same destination and you'll have found happiness in love.
  
  I like that analogy. Is the blessing of a traveling companion measured by miles shared? Of course not. They had and will have their own adventures apart from yours. Pretending otherwise is just immature, but demanding otherwise is selfish.
  Yet many do. “Me or no one” exclusivity under “till death” contracts are considered normal. The coercive nature of these relationship parameters are rarely considered, and neither is their cost, many of which relate to consent.
  This is where I usually get pushback so I’ll explain. For simplicity, consider the typical (sexual) consent scenario, where Alice gives Bob consent but withdraws it later. Can Bob retain her consent by getting her to sign a written contract? No. But what if the contract just prevented her from leaving? Again, no. But what if the contract specified an incentive she forfeits by leaving? Legal, but no. But what if the contract made him her only option without forfeiture? Again, legal, but no.
  Perhaps, having signed such a contract, Alice might acquiesce, and may even be enthusiastic at times. But sadly, Bob just put a lot of effort into making it difficult for him to ever know for sure, because “to have and to hold” Alice was more important to him than her freedom and happiness.
  This is why I insist on relationships that are explicitly open from the start. It’s not important to me to have multiple partners, but it is absolutely essential to me to be chosen freely. Not in exchange for anything. Not to fulfill a promise, duty, or obligation. Simply their current preference and desire. The result is I can be certain in each moment that my partners want me for me. Not my status or money or security I provide. Just me. And my life is so much better for it, because that kind of trust is precious and, apparently, quite rare.
  
  Thank you for posting this. I'm on something of a journey myself, and needed this advice.
- Marriage isn’t about claiming someone else for yourself. It’s about pledging yourself to another.

Shitting on Poly people seems still fashionable.
I think I understand why people hate on them. First, cheaters in monogamous relationships. What people don't realize is that there are cheaters in Poly relationships to. It's actually a ton of extra work making sure everyone and their wishes are respected.
Second, religious fundamentalists. People think of Mormons mostly when thinking of Poly people. Misogyny, religous indoctrination, all the worst shit you can think of. Not all Poly people are religious you know.
Polyamorus people deserve marriage equality. They deserve to love the way they want.
- Ive seen about 5 open marriage relationships first hand as part of my social circle, and maybe another 10 open dating relationships in the same expanded social circle. All hetero relationships, and I'd say slightly more than half of them were initiate by the woman. All "progressive" / non-religious poly.
  This has been about a 15 year period, and every single one of those relationships at this point is over, or on deaths door.
  My closest friend at one point was one of those, and I watched him slowly get more and more depressed over 6-8 months before opening up to me about it. He was critical of me passing judgement on poly relationships until I told him "OTHER people are capable of poly relationships. YOU are not." And that's really my only criticism to poly stuff. It is possible to be two well adjusted people participating in a long term mutually consensual polyamorus relationship. But those are about as common as rolling a natural 20 in the sample set of poly relationships. The rest are just headed for the garbage and at least one person in the relationship already knows it.
  Real Polyamorus deserve marriage equality and to love the way they want. Most of the others are just virtue signaling and wearing it like a fashion statement, which is why they get made fun of.
- I think a lot of people have the experience of dating someone who does not reveal they are poly until it is too “late.” I have a friend who is constantly meeting people and then learning that they already have a boyfriend, which is extremely frustrating.
  My ex husband also decided that he wanted to be poly. I was okay with it (I had no interest in pursuing other relationships myself) - but then he decided to throw our marriage away so he could chase legal teens half our age…
  The worst part is that you are supposed to feel “compersion” or something. It wasn’t enough to let my husband fuck teenagers, I had to be happy about it. It made me feel absolutely horrible and devastated my self esteem.
  The poly lifestyle also sort of encourages you to view relationships as means to an end and disposable. You see this person for your sex needs, this person for your emotional needs and so on. It’s not a lifetime partnership.
  
  Relationships are a lot of hard work. I don't get where people get the time to do that with multiple partners.
- Hating Mormons for polyamory is like hating Hitler for being vegan.

My opinion is fuck people like this that want you to conform to their standards of what a relationship is.
If you can have a happy and healthy relationship with someone without having sex with them? That awesome and you don't have to give a single shit what losers like the OOP think about you.

Maybe. If you don’t want to fuck anyone you should probably get depression treatment before a divorce. If you want to fuck someone new and not your wife then divorce. If you want both, nonmonogamy may be for you, but polyamory involves far less sex than you hope.
- Hmm that's interesting. I thought it was mostly sexual.
  
  There are people like that. You hear about their new partners all the time and see them constantly looking for new partners. That's not because poly is like that, but because these are the same people who would be serially monogamous if they wanted monogamy.
  For me, monogamy just felt too restrictive. My wife and I both broke up with people who wanted monogamy not long before meeting and have always been poly. As a 22 year old I loved the idea of sex, but nearing 30 I love that I can have multiple happy and long term relationships. I love the fact that I could fall in love with someone new without risking losing my wife who I love dearly and cherish. And yeah I’ve been in two happy relationships for about 5 years now. And both my partners like each other and I like my girlfriend’s husband
  
  for a lot of people in long term polyamory, it's about intimacy, which sex is part of. even if you have relationships that are primarily about fun sexy times, you're probably going to do a lot of scheduling to maintain those relationships, or find new ones.
  
  And today you learned you thought wrong.
  You may be thinking of "swinging" or some other variant of non monogamy.
  
  The old saw is that its mostly scheduling and deconflicting
  
  Don't worry it's just like when furries say it's not sexual
  Like OK we'll nod and smile and maybe they're the golden case but everyone else is sex obsessed - poly community drama is always about sex.
  
  It's not mostly sexual, it's entirely sexual. As in, sex is the entire point of being in any kind of non-monogamous relationship.
  You know what you call a relationship that doesn't have sex? A platonic friendship. If it really wasn't about the sex, then they would call them friends.
  EDIT: I see I've gotten the polysexual people angry with pointing out their bullshit. :D

Sounds like someone who is offended people live a lifestyle other then their preferred one and I feel it's best to just ignore this person.
- That's exactly what this sounds like, or maybe someone who doesn't know what their book is about
  
  Yep. And I'm not even poly. It would never work for me. But I'm not gonna be removed to other people because I don't live their lifestyle. This is exactly the same as telling gay people to just go fuck a person of the opposite gender.

I want my wife to fuck me.
- Woah there buddy. This genie can't make somebody to fall in love with you.

Love is not the same as sex. Heinlein said it well with "the more someone loves, the more they CAN love".
Different people can fill different needs. As long as all people involved are in agreement, then it's nobody else's business.
Mrs Grundy can take a hike off a cliff.

Asexual people and relationships exist
Also what does lack of sex have to do with polyamory?
- They weren't implying a lack of sexual desire altogether. They were implying someone who was no longer attracted to their spouse but wanted to have sex with other people instead would just call themselves poly instead of getting a divorce...
  Like how all those cishet guys go through years of emotional and hormone therapy, multiple surgeries, etc, so they can perv out in the women's restroom by calling themselves trans. Obviously /s

It's kind of weird because I agree a healthy marriage requires a healthy sex life with your partner, but at the same time I don't think a marriage should be built upon the premise of sexual gratification nor be dependent solely on it.
As for Polyamory, though, I don't see it as good or bad in general. Might be better to cohabitate with larger groups as humanity moves forward, but it certainly complicates relationships.

What if I want to fuck my wife and another woman or man at the same time?
- Life's about goals friend!

WTH! People are answering this like it was a serious question??? I thought it was a joke, a meme or 'Terrible Facebook'
Just let people figure out their own relationships! If you feel one way then great. Dont force others to feel the same way as you though!

I joke with my spouse that we need to get a wife. With 2 kids there is more than enough work for 3 adults.
- I also "joke" about this. This late stage capitalism is killing us
  
  My wife and I both work full time. She is in a masters program nights and weekends. We have two elementary school aged kids. We barely get to interact. Another year to go. Fuck I'm tired.

This doesn't make sense. Is it supposed to say "a book about monogamy"? That would make a little more sense.
Edit: fix stupid phone autocorrect
- I think it's referrencing monogamous folks trying to save an obviously dead relationship with poly

I'm poly and just celebrated my 1 year Trio-versary today! Haven't seen any poly memes on here yet so it's funny it comes up today
- Happy Trio-versary...I'd end up forgetting it twice and having two disappointed partners!

Wonder if the poster took the moment to consider the millions of folks out there who physically can't have sex anymore due to circumstances outside their control when they wrote this 🤔

I may have a strange definition of marriage that might come from my complete lack of religion. Churches are, after all, mostly in the business of being not okay with the subject of genitalia, which is mostly what has shaped the "institution of marriage."
I would like to have a long-term friend, a non-blood relative I have known for a long time, whose character I can vouch for, someone approximately my age, to hold my power of attorney, as my insurance beneficiary, and stuff like that, and I to them. I need not ever pork this person. I need not live in the same house as this person.
I do not consider myself polyamorous, I'm not particularly interested in swinger wife swap whatever. I tend to prefer having lots of sex with one person. But, in the modern world, partners do come and go. Job opportunities arise (or more frequently jobs evaporate and they have to go back somewhere they can more easily afford) and it's completely insane to ask someone to follow you. Or you just get tired of each other. Legally attaching onesself to your favorite person to fuck does not seem like a viable financial strategy. Look how many people it destroys every year.
Perish the thought of having children.
So, the thing that other people have, where they've picked one human to be a roommate/permanent sexual partner/insurance beneficiary/person whose allowed to shit while you're taking a shower/eventual divorcee? I don't understand wanting this for yourself.
Signed,
A bachelor

Strangely, the only poly people I seem to come across are bi-guy in relationship with woman and female-to-male trans-man. I know other polycule types exist, but for that type, to paraphrases Rick Sanchez: "That just sounds like polygamy with extra (accepting) steps."

Maybe this is an unpopular opinion but I just don't think polyamory can work. It will never stay or remain balanced between them all, and simply doesn't work long term. Two people is already incredibly difficult on so many emotional and logistic levels, adding a third while also remaining the love and attraction equal is simply not sustainable.
- I am the type of person who cannot separate sexual relationships from romantic relationships. I used to think the same way you about open/poly relationshios and also "friends with benefits". Every time I'd seen one they ended badly with someone, like me, "catching feelings" and someone getting hurt.
  However, I recently found out that a couple in my friend group has an open marriage. They attend parties together and very much appear to be a loving couple like any other and, I believe, they are. They just also date and have sex with other people sometimes.
  I think it isn't for everyone. I also think that often someone is dissatisfied in a relationship and they think they can make it work with a third or open relationship... and it doesn't work out. But I'm convinced that for some people it absolutely works.
- Yeah, but mormons
  
  Mormons have never been about balancing or mutual respect.

To me, polyamory is in the same category as cuckolding in the sense that it's none of my business...but I think it's weird fetish.
I don't feel like it's possible to love multiple people simultaneously and equally. Anecdotally I know two people who have been in poly relationships and they were messy, both ending with one monogamous couple and the remaining person getting cast out.
I know that doesn't describe every poly relationship.. that's just my own secondhand experience and I haven't seen anything to offset it.
But....it's not my life so I wasn't gonna stop them. I just wouldn't recommend anyone try it
- Polyamory is not a fetish and is not related to sex at all. People who practice polyamory CAN have sex but that's not what polyamory is. The people who do poly just to get laid are the ones that fail.
  (Source: currently engaged to my fiancé and about to celebrate my 1 year with my bf. Nothing sexual about it... Just a lot of love)
  
  Glad it's working for you. I think too many people get caught up in the idea without thinking it through which inevitably leads to fallout.
- I think this might be the worst post in this thread.
  Like, you admit you have no experience and don't really know what you're talking about, but you didn't let that stop you.
  
  OP literally asked "what is your opinion" to an open forum

I just feel bad for all the children who are unwittingly created and raised by these poly fetish people.
- Polyamory is not a fetish
- Yep, all those kids who get more attention, more love, more money, more education... Really feel bad for them. Maybe one day they'll be lucky and have a single parent who works all the time like I did. 🙄
  
  I know a poly couple. They have a toddler. The kid is well loved.
  The kid doesn't think the other partners being around is "weird". That's a thing you'd have to teach kids.
- Okay Karen.
- And it would be weird to have a poly parent just vacate from your life because they have no technical legal rights to see you.
  
  You do understand that two people can not be married, and have kids together, right? Just because they're not married doesn't mean the mom or dad has no legal rights to the kid. The father is the father regardless of the relationship status of the parents and same for the mother.
  Also, my dad wasn't poly, and he vacated my life all on his own.
  
  You do realize that lots of people have friends that perform parenting roles with their kids, right? E.g. Couples who are friends that each babysit for each other.
  The event of the friendship ending has the same psychological effect on the children as having a poly partner leave the relationship.
  A lot of these imagined "harms" and weird situations are regular events that people already experience. It's the defamiliarization of seeing it in a setting that you perceive as weird that makes it seem harmful and/or weird.

138 comments