14h ago

Is there a uBlock Origin filter or extension for LLM slop in search results

63 comments

DuckDuckGo has a “hide ai images” setting. It seems it also blocks these videos. I’m not getting any of those videos in your screenshot if I search on DDG.
- Kagi too. https://blog.kagi.com/slopstop
  But YouTube is basically just a slop bucket.
  
  Wh arts so good about kagi? I looked it up once and I saw a subscription and a focus on ai and I noped out.
  
  That Kagi Linux browser they've been teasing for the last few months can't come out fast enough! I wrote this comment on Firefox+ublock btw

You can use uBlacklist with a list of AI websites to filter out a ton of crap in search results. It's good for blocking out AI slop websites but probably won't be too effective for individual YouTube videos.

No. Ublock blocks elements, it does not look at the contents.
- If there were something in the elements indicating it, it could, but that seems unlikely.
- It could block websites/CDNs that host them if such a list existed though.
  
  Sooo... YouTube?

Youtube is pretty much unusable now, more than half the videos are low effort Ai slop, and the rest is just irrelevant, leaving the real content buried deep down in the algorithm.
Edit: I forgot to mention that I don't use an YouTube account and haven't used for years for privacy reasons. I'm mostly speaking about using the search function without an account.
- YouTube has a great algorithm, in that it mostly seems to show you stuff you actually want to watch, and let's you say you don't like stuff.
  You can train it with a little effort to show you what you want.
  You just can't make the shorts go away, even with premium!
  
  You can on mobile with modified client and I belive there's browser extensions that remove shorts on pc
  
  They added a shorts limit though. It prevents you from watching more than 15 minutes of shorts a day. Experimentally afterwards it seems to recommend slightly fewer shorts in your feed.
- Used to be I'd scroll through the suggested videos, and find new content creators based on my interests.
  Now? I don't trust clicking on a new unheard of youtuber channel. 90% of the time it's just AI crap.
- Maybe it's just my algorithm but I don't think I've been presented any slop videos. Surely not long videos, right?
- Stop using the algorithm. Take your existing known likes and go search them out for their collaborators. Search out creators not single videos on a topic.
- Try FreeTube, turn off all recommendations and subscribe to the channels you like. It's great.
- It's gotten so bad the past year especially. I often open an incognito tab to look something up or watch a video without affecting my recommendations, and every time I do, the logged out YouTube recommendations are worse and worse. Genuine bottom of the barrel fuck shit dog ass slop. If it was illegal to produce slop like this I genuinely think the world would be a slightly better place (or even just making it illegal to monetize it).
- To get YouTube to work you need to curate your watch history. Any video you regret watching should be deleted from history so that it won’t be used for recommendations.
  If your history is filled with these bad videos then you’re better off wiping your history entirely. Then start from scratch watching only videos that really interest you and your recommendations will all be based on those.
  Like the internet itself, there is a TON of great content on YouTube. The trouble is finding it! For me, the internet has been gradually reverting to the situation I remember from the mid-90s (before Google existed). There were lots of search engines but they were pretty much all bad. I relied a lot on word of mouth (and site-to-site links) to find things.
- I don’t use an YouTube account and haven’t used for years for privacy reasons.
  Same here. Trick is to not use the YT search function. My strategy changes depending on specifically what I'm looking for, but in general for anything factual I start with a no-AI text search on DDG and then go to YT once I know what I want to see, or just use DDG to trawl through the videos. It's not perfect but it cuts out a LOT of the slop.
  For entertainment, if my current list of "known good" seems exhausted, I keep my subscriptions in FreeTube and go with the recommendations there where I can hide channels more effectively, but that's pretty rare because I collect what look like promising channels as I go along in regular browsing, like Lemmy or news articles, and not from any algorithm.
- have you used bitview?
- If you use it with an account and have watch history its really quite good at recommending relevant stuff.
  I think it also depends on what you're searching for though, like if I search for a guide on changing fork seals on my motorcycle the results are pretty much fine.
- I mean it literally doesn't load. If you have been able to use YT in the past year, your browser is seriously insecure.

Kagi has an LLM community register they automatically use to filter their results

before:2022 might work

Who is the target audience for that ? Who the fuck even neds instructions to verify a damn email address, much less a whole ass youtube video ?
- People who have never been online before, people who don’t understand the meaning of the phrase (ESL etc), children
- Why is OP searching for it?
  
  I was looking for an image of reddit's award/badge that they put on profiles
  
  I'll give OP the benefit of the doubt and say that perhaps they searched for something else but it had enough overlap with keywords that the slop is targeting that their seemingly more niche search is getting drowned out

“It seemed to me,” said Wonko the Sane, “that any civilization that had so far lost its head as to need to include a set of detailed instructions for use in a package of toothpicks, was no longer a civilization in which I could live and stay sane.”

I did not need the information in this video, but it's only a matter of time before helpful guides are overwhelmed with this shit

That really paints a dark future

There is this blocklist:
https://github.com/laylavish/uBlockOrigin-HUGE-AI-Blocklist
- Thank you !

But how do I verify my email on Reddit?
- It's a truly complicated task

I wonder if sponsor skip's database can be repurposed to include ai slop publishers
- Amazing idea
- I forgot about that. DeArrow would work great for this.
  If it cannot remove the video, it can at least replace slop video titles and thumbnails with a blank rectangle and an empty space character.

I can advise anyone to install DeArrow.
Instead of having every thumbnail screaming at me, YouTube is now much calmer in general. Even the clickbait titles are replaced by crowdsourced alternatives.
No more "TOP 5 Reasons Why You SHOULD use/not use something ❌❌/✅✅", but "review of something" instead.
- I'm torn cause I use smart tube & revanced to avoid ads, but I really want something like this but not enough to deal with the bullshit 3-5 ads every five minutes.
  
  Revanced has dearrow built in. It's in the alternative thumbnails menu
  
  you can use DeArrow with revanced, I do.

Ironically you need AI to detect AI output in the content offered to you and to block it. Though in theory some heuristics for the visuals in the thumbnails could work.

I don't see anything like this in search, even DuckDuck.
What do you have on that you see this? (Or what have I turned off?)
I do use Ublock and Noscript, but they don't list anything to block on search engines, really.