Plenty of them seem to have just memory-holed it. I check on the posts of one very random extreme right winger occasionally, and I'm guessing she didn't like his post because she's posted twice as much today as she usually does. But it's all just her normal talking points: A Bible verse, Mamdani's rent control will hurt poor people, election fraud "pass the save act" reminders, and Obama/Biden/communists open borders child trafficker conspiracies. It's like she's trying to drown out the the information she doesn't want to hear.
They're very effectively siloed off in their social media echo chambers, this is why that 33% support number doesn't move. In my opinion, the number of articles about "they're finally outraged" just lulls people into a false sense of security and obscures actual developments.
Omnipotence implies the ability to control emotions (along with everything else). Were God only framed as being omniscient, then your answer could explain it. It's a bit harder to ignore the gap for omnipotence.
OP's question is a version of the classic Omnipotence Paradox: "Can God make a rock so heavy he can't lift it?", which has had a good couple of thousand years worth of discussion, but no particularly satisfying answers. I doubt lemmy will have a breakthrough, but no harm in trying.