1y ago

Transgender women banned from women's chess events - BBC News

www.bbc.com Transgender women banned from women's chess events - BBC News

The ruling by the International Chess Federation is drawing criticism from some players.

The International Chess Federation (FIDE) says it is temporarily banning transgender women from competing in its women's events.

The FIDE said individual cases would require "further analysis" and that a decision could take up to two years.

The move has been criticised by some players and enthusiasts.

Many sports governing bodies have been working on policies towards transgender athletes, but chess does not involve comparable levels of physical activity.

25 comments

Isn't this just assuming "women aren't smart enough to compete with a biologically male brain"?
When we're talking about physical sports I understand why there's debate, but why TF are they doing it in fucking mental sports?
- Because it was all bad faith transphobia all along

This is a disturbing and insulting decision to both cis-women as well as transgender men and women.
Besides the decision itself, here are some additional "gems" that show its backwardness:
Transgender men who transition after winning women's titles would see those titles "abolished," the federation said, while holding out the possibility of a reinstatement "if the person changes the gender back to a woman."
"If a player has changed the gender from a man into a woman, all the previous titles remain eligible," the federation said.
And, if it wouldn't be so sad, this here would have me roling on the floor. It seems, FIDE has not reached 2023 yet.. (It also sadly shows that even some women are still stuck in the 1950's)
A top global chess official Friday called for more research into whether factors such as hormone levels and physical endurance might have an impact on players' abilities at the male-dominated game. Her comments came after the world chess federation was heavily criticized for its decision to block transgender women from official women's events. (...)
(...)"What is still not clear is if the hormonal levels do influence the competitiveness in chess," Reizniece-Ozola said by video from Latvia's capital, Riga. "There is no serious research or scientific analysis that would prove one or the other way. There are speculations, but no more than that."
One of the reasons why so few women play chess and the reality of what female chess players had and have to fight against:
UK MP Angela Eagle, who was a joint winner of the 1976 British Girls' Under-18 chess championship, said: "There is no physical advantage in chess unless you believe men are inherently more able to play than women - I spent my chess career being told women's brains were smaller than men's and we shouldn't even be playing."
"This ban is ridiculous and offensive to women," she added.
Edit: removed redundancy
- Jfc, you'd think that people so deep into a game that is touted as being an intellectual pursuit would be able to use their brain better than that.
  
  I think it's because it's touted that way. Men who are pro-patriarchy or toxically masculine are kind of notoriously prestige selfish and love to narrow the playing field of women because their perceived masculinity is threatened by any notion of equality.
  This is why my local game shop holds girls nights for Magic the Gathering. It's not that women are inherently worse at the game, it's because the open play harassment and terrible behaviour drives a lot of women out of the hobby before they have the chance. Trans women are absolutely subject to this same misogyny because they represent to these douches the same threat. They can never be allowed to be proven superior in any fashion because of all the mysoginistic /transphobic beliefs that they are mentally ill and/or weaker because they do not agree being bearded chest pounding ape children is the apex human form. The prize of prestige must be protected from falling into the hands of someone who will "immasculate" them so they rig the fucking game so their precious dick wagging contests never damage their fragile masculinity. To have someone who isn't masculine win is to damage the prestige itself.
  Chess champions get treated like geniuses so of course this particular psychosis applies.
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S019188691400261X
  This study is very interesting, evidently Georgian chess has been historically equal.
  
  Equally interesting study comes to the conclusion: gender differences in chess go back on the overrepresentation of men in chess in general
  Article on the research: Why Men Rank Higher than Women at Chess (It's Not Biological)
  I don't have access to what seems to be the actual study, but maybe you do: Why are (the best) women so good at chess? Participation rates and gender differences in intellectual domains
  
  Is posting the same link 3 times in the same thread enough?
- This is a disturbing and insulting decision to both cis-women as well as transgender men and women.
  No, it's a fucking insult to human intelligence
  
  You are allowed to read scientific studies BEFORE you begin literally shaking.
  https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S019188691400261X

Well, Fuck The International Chess Federation (FIDE). And fuck whoever downvoted me.

Yikes!

I'd say this is a textbook example of the Patriarchy at play here. Use of institutions to systemically undermine women's agency.
I just never thought that an international Chess organization would be the one to do it.

25 comments