Skip Navigation

Fediverse @lemmy.ml

Blaze @discuss.tchncs.de

1y ago

This still baffles me, but I guess it's good for federation?

Context: https://sh.itjust.works/comment/2181865

You're viewing a single thread.

394 comments

Good. Piracy is illegal and immoral.
- But I want to make sleazy companies suffer...
  
  Become a film director or major video game developer and have your content ruthlessly stolen then.
  
  I can't, can't afford to go to college or watch films or read plays to become a better director, programmer, writer. Maybe I'm unemployed too :( fuck me, right?
  
  Then write them and don't steal. And everybody is financially suffering so don't use that excuse.
  
  Haha, I feel solace in knowing that we suffer together, pull yourself up by your flipflop straps, right?
  
  Okay but be creative and don't steal.
  
  Ok, I'll go to chatgpt then
  
  ChatGPT is AI and AI is theft.
  
  Ok, fine, at least you're consistent.
  
  This coment is my Idea I had it first give me yur updoots!!!
  
  Okay but be creative and don’t steal.
  You've all witnessed theft just now!
  
  What? Originality is theft?
  
  Theft because they copied your comment.
  
  Proof of criminality.
  
  Even then it'd hardly be my problem
  
  Okay.
  
  when the capitalists expropriate the profits over creative works: cool, good
  when some random person downloads it: how dare you
- Copyright infringement is absolutely the moral thing to do in quite a lot of cases. For example, for the preservation of cultural works. Corporations aren't exactly spending their money on proper archives and the people to curate them. Quite the opposite! For example, if some or all of the lawsuits against sites like archive.org are successful then the result could be a mass erasure of cultural works on the scale of the burning of the Library of Alexandria.
  
  But archiving has nothing to do with copyright.
  
  Yes it absolutely does.
  
  No.
  
  I wish the courts feel the same way
  
  This is such an insane thing to say, I feel like you can't possibly understand what those words mean.
- Sorry can't hear you too busy downloading communism
- oh no, billionaire profits. anyway,,
- 💬
- Me playing a small violin very emotionally at the thought that a media mogul won't be able to afford his 750th super yacht because of piracy 😢
- It's like stealing a car.
  
  You wouldn't download a car.
  
  Of course not, cars are immoral
  
  Not over lemmy.world's internet connection with that "uptime", definitively!
  
  I would if I could.
  
  You know I would. For now I can at least download this and send it to them.
  
  Exactly. Illegal and immoral. You get a cookie.
  
  Whoosh
  
  So you like stealing vehicles too?
  
  Only hand drawn ones or e.g. 🚓 I stole this one from the interwebs. Now you saw it, you gotta pay the owner. THOUGHT CRIMe
  
  I'm surprised we're not all out stealing cars right now.
  
  You're part of the reason why crime is so desensitized.
  
  Ha..
  It was a reference to Letterkenny btw.
  
  Ok, I'm not sure if you're for real, but I have a feeling you're one of the dudes with the writers/actors strike and I have to say that as someone who hates barriers to knowledge I also respect your struggle to keep doing what you love. I just feel like studios are getting too greedy on both ends in an attempt to prop up unsustainable profit margins, thus making it hard to afford services and hard to live on the wages they pay.
  /rant That said, scientific paper publishers are another beast and the worst offenders (e.g. see a paper related to climate change for 48 hours, 40$) many researchers don't get paid to write the paper or even pay to have it published, only to see it paywalled, so nobody will even read it legally, so they can oversharge universities. /rant off
  
  Re: rant. Yeah, normally none of that goes to the authors of the paper. So you’re not really taking anything away from them.
  
  Also, I have read about academic gatekeeping scams and how you can email the authors who are glad to CONSENSUALLY provide you with access to knowledge.
  
  Most of the ones I know will thank you if you just find their work and don't add one more email to their already full mailbox 😎 it's another culture.
  
  I have done that a couple of times.
  
  I am not an actor. I don't have the coordination or speech consistency for that endeavor. But yes, I am for real. All of a sudden having an opinion, a remarkably controversial one at that, means that I'm a troll. I tend to get adamant about opinions. Good that I'm not a politician or... ha.
- Idk about immoral lol debatable for sure
  
  Then debate it.

394 comments