Programming.dev is still running Lemmy 0.19.5, and they had a quite severe issue of database corruption for 3 months. Thankfully, it's solved since (https://programming.dev/post/20515601)
People are not going to copy paste their relevant comments to the 7 crossposts of the same article.
I don't see how every comment section has to be identical, although in the case of privacy/security maybe there are cases where important information is shared in the comments, idk.
Let's imagine that someone comes up with a detailed analysis of what is happening with the new ToC, and which alternative people could consider switching too. Do you think they'll go through the hassle of sharing that information to all of those threads?
Do you think theyโll go through the hassle of sharing that information to all of those threads?
I can't predict the future, I can only say that I personally have shared comments (with links) that I found insightful before, and I'd hope others would do the same if it was important enough. And sure, time on this earth is limited, but when I want to know something I trawl many comment sections to get a better picture.
Would it be easier to gather important tips if there were less sublemmies? Yes, undoubtedly, but my original point about redundancy, as the instances are all hosted different places in the world, is also a positive thing.