Car insurance prices surge
Car insurance prices surge
Car insurance rates are surging as Americans struggle to pay for basic necessities and ongoing debt.
Car insurance rates are surging as Americans struggle to pay for basic necessities and ongoing debt.
The newest Consumer Price Index shows car insurance spiked 20 percent year over year. The surge in pricing occurred after years of gradual price inflation, with earlier reports finding the rates grew by 36 percent since 2020.
That's at the same time debt is soaring for many Americans. While Americans hold around 1.75 trillion in student debt loans alone, they also have $1.05 trillion in credit card balances not paid off.
Anecdotal but Liberty Mutual increased my rates annually, refused to lower cause I was at lowest rate possible (supposedly, even recalculating as a new customer). Went from 135 to 150 to 170 at last renewal. Then after contract renew I get hit for 205. Said they adjusted rates for everyone in my area and tough shit. And then had the audacity to demand 127 after I canceled my policy because it was a few days after a payment, and they claimed to have charged for the previous month. I remember paying the first month upon signing up with them, not as “accrued”, but a month and then being covered between them and the next payment.
Left them to State Farm and went from 156/month for 6 months DOWN to 125/month at renewal for 6 months. New Hyundai Venue (not one they refuse to insure due to theft), full coverage but the lowest possible.
I’m still mad about it but happy I left.
Shop around. Your loyalty means nothing to them.
I've been with State Farm for 20 years. Actual agent I have met with a few times. Have had one or two claims over the years and they worked with me pretty reasonably. My rates have never "jumped" but have had what I'd consider some minor bumps over the years. Of the many companies I've dealt with, they're one that has at least not given me a huge headache.
I don't have anything to do with them other than being a client, and mileage always varies, this is just my experience. I call out a lot of shitty companies, seems worth letting others know if one isn't terrible. (Also, I live in a major metro, no idea what it would be like someplace else.)
Same, I'm with State Farm and meet with my agent every few years to make sure my coverage makes sense. The last time I met with her she was able to get me better coverage for what I need at a lower monthly cost. My rates have gone up and down a little over the years, but nothing major in either direction.
- People insist on driving larger cars, creating more severe accidents.
- People insist on driving more expensive cars, driving up replacement and repair costs.
- People insist on outlawing speed cameras and red light cameras, driving up accident rates and severity.
- People insist on increasing speed limits, increasing accident rates and severity.
- Roads and merge lanes are poorly designed as governments cut corners. Again, this increases accident rates and severity.
- States don’t test drivers regularly for competence. This means impaired drivers and poorly skilled drivers remain on the road, causing accidents.
- Urban police forces no longer enforce traffic laws in many cities, increasing accident rates.
- Some states are getting rid of car inspections. Which means more cars with bad tires and no headlights and more accidents.
Add inflation and greedflation, and It’s no wonder insurance rates are higher.
People insist on outlawing speed cameras and red light cameras, driving up accident rates and severity.
I can't speak for your state, but red light cameras started being a great source of revenue from fines, so people started rigidly adhering to them. So this caused two problems.
-
While there were less T-bone accidents meaning people running red lights and hitting perpendicular traffic, all other types of accidents increased by 18% because people were hard stopping so as not to get fined and getting rear ended. source. So if your point is lower costs because of fewer accidents, Red light cameras increased accidents.
-
Because people were not running lights anymore, the fines from red light cameras went down. The money was so good that cities got greedy, they started randomly decreasing yellow light times to cause more people to run red lights to increase fines again video source
Also in my area people started shooting out the redlight cameras cause they were fining people who were following the law to a T. The cops were outright working with the city maintenance guys to cut the wire on the damned things because they were getting pissed having to deal with the complaints.
-
Red light cameras cause accidents because people slam on their brakes too hard.
You forgot the big part
As an example, progressive insurance
It’s more profitable to raise rates, and they can get away with it
Some of these are valid. But speed cameras do fuck all for safety. They are a private company scam to take money from people
The better way to go about it is to redesign roadways to force people to slow down. Narrower lanes, trees on each side, no more 6-lane highways through semi-residential and mixed-use areas. And then invest in public transportation so that fewer people even need to drive their own cars.
But I'm preaching to the choir on Lemmy and hoping for hell to freeze over.
Thanks for pointing that out.
Those first two, the "people" are largely the auto manufacturers.
Smaller and cheaper cars are SUPER popular in the rest of the world and are literally not available at all in the US. The auto mfgs will tell you it is because of US preference, but in a country of 330 million, there doesn't need to be that much demand compared to these vehicles popularity in, say, a cheese-loving nation of 65 million. Even if they are immensely less popular, there is still MORE than enough market for some of these ALREADY-BEING-PRODUCED vehicles.
But the US auto mfgs refuse. They go bigger and more expensive. The US consumer has no real choice.
For your fourth and fifth, the "people" are US civil/transportation engineers. They must be stopped. They are a scourge. There's no culture of safe road engineering in the US. AASHTO are an association of insane fuckwits.
I am incredibly skeptical that the behaviors of US drivers are significantly different than anywhere else in the world. I'm pretty skeptical of worries over inspections or licensing requirements and am CERTAIN that additional police enforcement will only cause more mayhem and death and not protect any life. I believe it's almost entirely a problem of road engineering, urban design, and vehicle design.
Mfgs also don’t produce as many of the base trims so it limits choice further. Then on top of that the dealers tend to mark cars way up. Cars in general are just way overpriced since COVID started and some mfgs are still claiming supply chain issues so they artificially limit supply further.
People insist on driving more expensive cars, driving up replacement and repair costs.
It's not like the average US consumer has a say in this. The cheapest car you can drive off a lot is like 25k now. We could have less expensive cars but for half a century we've used tariffs to provide an unfair competitive advantage to our domestic motor companies who only took advantage of it to price gouge.
You’re missing the part where people spend $80k cars on a loan each five years because they are financially illiterate.
Another factor (in the US at least) is over-litigation of any and all traffic incidents. Seems like the default practice now is to get lawyers involved for a fender bender that breaks one tail light. The "at fault" drivers insurance ends up using lawyers to go back and forth haggling with the "victim" drivers lawyers and they finally settle on some ridiculous payment that is 10x what the actual damage was. All that cost gets passed on to everybody who buys car insurance.
Speed limits dont decrease acidents. They are the most famous example of a safety feature not working
This list is true and depressing. People in this country should not be running it. It's a daycare run by children.
-
People insist on driving larger cars, creating more severe accidents.
-
People insist on driving more expensive cars, driving up replacement and repair costs.
Electric cars are a contributing factor to both of these trends.
With respect to more expensive cars, people don't have a choice.
-
Could be related. Low credit scores can lead to higher insurance prices. But that doesn't seem right because the actual risk shouldn't have likely changed. Could be higher repair costs. Of course simple corporate greed could be to blame. Didn't need to actually say that one did I?
My car insurance went up $1200 this year, which blows my mind. No reason given.
Two years ago I was paying 1300 a year now I'm paying 1700 for six months and I've literally had nothing change in my driving record.
Used car prices went up, new car prices went up, collision repair prices went up, and repair time increased significantly. We also saw a huge increase in accident severity and a growing trend toward more aggressive driving.
My car insurance went up $1200 this year, which blows my mind. No reason given.
Kind of like jobs. If you stay with the same company for more than a couple years, you're probably doing yourself a disservice.
What car do you have? Is it a Kia or Hyundai?
Chevy Volt and a Town & Country.
My car insurance went up $1200 this year, which blows my mind. No reason given.
Damn, what the hell. I pay about 15% of that for comprehensive coverage here in Germany. I guess that evens it out with the cheap fuel that you guys have.
I live in a no-fault state, which I love, but our insurance rates here are among the highest in the nation.
No fault insurance just means my insurance pays me, not whomever I get into an accident with. I do business with a company I trust to take care of me, so I don't have to care if I'm in an accident with someone with shit insurance.
Not everyone here is a fan due to high prices, but I like it. I've seen too many friends in other states get low-ball offers that they either had to accept or be without a car for weeks while they appeal.
Ironically, it wouldn't matter because the only accidents I've been involved in were with deer (who are notorious for carrying no insurance) so I've never been in an accident where no fault actually helped me.
Geico gave me a reason, "The reason why we are increasing your rate is because there are more people in your area who drive without insurance"
I'm sorry, but how the fuck is that my problem? Also, isn't that the whole fucking point of the full cover insurance I am required to pay while I'm making payments on the car?
I’m sorry, but how the fuck is that my problem? Also, isn’t that the whole fucking point of the full cover insurance I am required to pay while I’m making payments on the car?
Insurance always wins. If you have full coverage they have to pay when you get hit by them. They don't want to pay.
Imagine buying a new car in 2024
I wouldn't buy any car made after like 2005 anyway, way too much computerized crap and too many important parts made out of aluminum or plastic.