[Vote] Only those with an account on this instance should vote on the Agora.

Those in favor reply "Aye"

Those against reply "Nay"

You're viewing a single thread.

214 comments

Nay, I thought half the point was that "the instance you join doesn't matter much." I'd generally like more cohesion, not walled communities that you need 5 different accounts for.
Edit: I want to add to this. Nowhere in the community description here does it say it's meant for sh.itjust.works community discussion/voting. I think there's value in a community closed to sh.itjust.works that ONLY discusses sh.itjust.works relevant topics/polls. But this isn't the community for it.
- I'm still an Aye.
  I already have 4 accounts on different instances, which is useful while Beehaw does their defederation thing. Part of this decentralized federation is that each instance gets to make it's own rules on how it operates. Why should members of one instance get to make all the rules for another one?
  If someone wants to make an account and participate in the growth of this particular instance then they're already vested in this community.
  
  This is exactly how I feel. Maybe I need to re-read theDude's OP about the direction of the instance but I thought this was a place to discuss the Administration of this instance, so why would people from other instances get the same say and input? You don't vote for other country's elections...
  
  If you read the community description, nowhere does it say this is a place to discuss admin of this instance. That's my issue. If we want a place for that, I totally agree there's value in that. But either the description needs to be completely changed or it needs to be somewhere else.
  
  A simple line added to the top of the description that this is meant to be "the agora (of sh.itjust.works)" would fix that. The description made sense to me when I read it and implied that already but that's probably because I came here immediately after reading the original post announcing this place and it's purpose.
- I was all for Aye but you do make a good argument. Especially since I was thinking of spinning up my own instance for just me. On the other hand it's not that difficult (at least right now) to just spin up an account here to have a vote.
  I do think it makes sense that the people who call their instance home get to call the shots though.
  For example: Beehaw. Their admins defederated sh.itjust.works because they wanted to. Fair, idk but their choice.
  Edit: looks the Dude has a similar opinion. https://sh.itjust.works/comment/296455
  
  Fair enough, I just sort of think it goes against the concept of federation. I'm also strongly considering spinning up my own instance, and I'd like it if that option didn't include the caveat of "you don't actually get to interact with anything, join those specific communities to interact." That's just a collection of reddit alternatives that sort of talk to each other. Meh.
  
  Agreed. Kinda leaves you a Lemmy nomad which doesn't feel great.

214 comments