Trust me bro
Trust me bro
Comments
35-
-
They're confusing knowledge for function calling. If you say "what's my nearest thingy?" It will call into a function in the app which will get your GPS coordinates to find a "thingy" near to there. and the result will be posted back to the LLM to serve you the result in human language. TheLLM doesn't know anything that isn't in the training / fine-tuning data, the context data, or function call results.
-
For those who believe AGI is right around the corner, this is just splitting hairs. The end result for AGI would be that it can discover your location easily, by making the function call, while still adamantly claiming it doesn't "know".
"I don't know. I really don't know, but THAT guy knows, and he'll tell me if I ask. You didn't ask if I can find out, only whether I know."
-
-
I'm presuming that the "scare" is that you didn't give it location perms? Although that looks like Snapchat, which I remember having location perms.
-
You can use Snapchat without giving location permissions. It's just that several features don't work without it
Disclaimer: At least the last time I used it, this was the case (maybe 6 months ago?)
-
-
About the Town - Town of Tonawanda
403 forbidden
Welcome To the City of Tonawanda, NY
403 forbidden
-
Everything you need to know about Tonawanda in two sentences: It's a polluted shithole located on the Niagara River in close proximity to Buffalo, it is a former sundown town who took down their last "Sundowners Neighborhood Watch" sign in 2020. There is a cult following for the Buffalo Bills, potholes the size of baby elephants, and several rails to trails paths.
It's been several years since I've been there and do not anticipate returning at any point.
-
Upvoting for the "rails to trails paths." I like when cities make those.
-
Ah I had always wondered, I lived across the river from it. In all my years in the Niagara area I don't think I actually went to NF, USA or its surrounding towns. Then again I've heard stories about NF, USA and it didn't spark in me an interest to go there. Buffalo was always nice though
-
-
Works from a Phoenix AZ IP (current vpn server until I swap after posting this.) Prob blocks foreign (to US) IPs.
-
Technicality that the llm doesn't, but the function it calls it there does.
I mean yes but also doesn't change the creep factor
It very very much does if you understand how that sausage is made.
To the untrained eye though, I feel that.
Of course it does.
That means that functionally the LLM has access to your location.
The tool needs to be running on your device to have access to the location, and apps can't/don't really call each other in the background, which means the chat app has access to your location, which means the LLM can request access to your location via the tool or the app can just send that information back to home base whenever it wants.
Correct.
I also know that iOS allows an approximate location to be sent to apps, which maybe is the case here.
Which doesn't take away from the creep factor let me set that straight.
I think that’s still a permission, by default it’s “general area” but you can also allow more fine grained location data
Its like saying i dont have access to your address, when the big book of everybody's address including yours is on the desk in front of me, that I can look at whenever required.
Plus your IP can often get you a pretty approximate location.
It can, or it can give a really incorrect impression
Far too many people think geolocating IP addresses is a lot more accurate than it is, since it usually shows a precise location. Over the years, geolocating IPv4 addresses has gotten less and less accurate
+/- half of my country.
Right MCP servers are a thing.