The "Backlash" to Plant-Based Meat Has a Sneaky, if Not Surprising, Explanation

sentientmedia.org The Backlash to Plant-Based Meat Has a Sneaky, if Not Surprising, Explanation

During the pandemic, plant-based meat consumption and media coverage exploded. Now, a host of trend pieces decry its demise. That shift is no organic accident.

cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/2674486

TL;DR: the meat industry's misleading messaging campaign + lobbying

vegan @lemmy.world

The "Backlash" to Plant-Based Meat Has a Sneaky, if Not Surprising, Explanation

sentientmedia.org /plant-based-backlash-explained/

34 4

Environment @beehaw.org

The "Backlash" to Plant-Based Meat Has a Sneaky, if Not Surprising, Explanation

sentientmedia.org /plant-based-backlash-explained/

113 40

You're viewing a single thread.

98 comments

I don't have any particular issues with plant based meats, but I really don't like the whole idea that everything has to replicate meat.
There are so many amazing dishes that just happen to be vegetarian/vegan that seem to go overlooked
- You often hear this take from non-vegans. If someone wants to make substitutes, what's the problem? Who cares?
  
  Making the good option easier is a good way to get people to do the right thing
  
  One thing many vegans don't get about non-vegans is that we're frustrated at veganism for the same "reasonable if not valid" reasons. I've had some vegan family/friends have serious health issues directly related to their refusal to eat meat. Yes, there's a lot to that, and it usually spawns from people easily prone to PTSD being made to watch some disgusting documentary about the meat packing industry and going full starvation on and off until all their hair fell out. Is it veganism's fault? Not directly.
  It's kinda like the Catholic Church. There's SO FEW pedophiles in the Catholic Church, but for anyone who has been touched by that, the Church itself is tainted far worse than the facts allow.
- Agreed, meat serves a specific role within traditional dishes. I find well cooked mushrooms to be one of the better substitutes in most sauce based dishes, though it lacks in protein. If we are going full vegan I believe South Indian to be some of the best cuisine in the world.
  There is so much flexibility in cooking. I got some beyond meat Jamaican patties this week and I just genuinely wasn’t impressed with the flavor and texture.
  I’d argue that bad implementation of substitutes is generally the culprit here. Meshing well with the cuisine is a better move. I’d rather have a curry rice with herbs filled patty.
  Anyway I guess my point is that making meat replacement options just taste “OK” isn’t doing a lot of favors.
- Many (probably most) vegetarians or vegans didn't start that way, so having the option to have some familiar foods without the meat is nice, beyond stuff for example is not cheap where I live, so it's a treat to have one, but sometimes you just feel like a greasy hamburger that tastes like beef
- For some people they need a sufficient meat replacement to be able to give up meat. People with ARFID for example who already have very limited food options and have a preference for meat can find it very difficult to just have vegetarian meals
- Because selfish humans love their fucking meat and they don’t care that animals are locked into prisons where they can barely move or clean themselves, generate massive acres of literal shit pools that pollute large areas, the impact that kind of farming has on the environment….
  THAT is why there is motivation for replication. Without it how do you shut down these disgusting cow/pig/chicken torture facilities
  
  Yet so many of these people that claim to care about the environment still have children. Hypocrisy at it's finest.
  
  Hard agree. People will call you an extemist like child free communities that hate kids, as if the state of the fucking world is reason enough to chill on the kids thing
  
  If you had to choose between being vegan and the environment going to shit, or eating meat and the environment getting figured out, which would you pick?
  I find a lot of vegans have a really inaccurate view of non-vegans wrt eating meat. It's not that we selfishly choose to eat meat despite feeling animals dying is a bad thing. It's that we don't think it's a bad thing that animals die in a farm for food.
  And if you realize that, you might find you have things in common with non-vegans. I fight for free-range laws, anti-farm-cruelty laws, etc. I just think you're morally in the wrong about everyone stopping eating meat. Oddly, a lot of us non-vegans see vegans to be selfish. But we try not to use that to be uncivil towards them.

98 comments