What are some games you like that most people hate and/or were panned by critics?

Aliens: Colonial Marines

IMO, the game is better than it's reputation - at least in it's current state. After the .ini tweak to fix the alien ai-typo makes it a bit better - afaik, I can't remember if my group played it with the fix or not, we've played the campaign at least 3 times now.

The game's not a masterpiece by any means, though. It is pretty enjoyable action game in COOP and fairly high difficulty. Sure, arguments could be made that any game is, but game still more fun than not. Now, would I play the game on my own, as single player? Eeeeeeeh, dunno... But if my gaming group asks to play some ACM, I'm down.

Some random points about the game summarized:

• Pulserifle goes BRRT, alien goes splat.
• Could do with less of the human/android enemies though, or at least the parts with androids felt like they dragged on for considerable time.
• Quite a bit of collectible guns, they're mostly sidegrades but they are different enough, imo.
• runs on a toaster
• goes for pennies on Steam sales, so gaming group funny hours per unit of currency -ratio is pretty good, imo.