9mo ago

RIP in pieces

You're viewing a single thread.

143 comments

Don't forget that he also didn't found Tesla
- Correct! He sued his way into being called a founder.
  I cant say I know what this shithead has contributed to society if anything but a place for toXicity to grow.
  
  Apparently the ghost of Elon doesn’t like this, telling from the downvotes
  
  I think he contributed to how we see billionaires now. The little money grabbing idiots which contribute nothing to society.
  
  We don't have to do this. Not everything is black and white. Tesla would not be where it is today without his intervention. I expect SpaceX wouldn't either.
  He's also a Nazi enabler and promoter.
  A person can do both good and bad.
  
  I don't think it's about whether what he did with Tesla is good (it is at least debatable whether it is unilaterally good given they are anti-competitive in the EV market). It's rather about the pretense for the good thing. Elon isn't driven to help the environment. The sum purpose of Tesla's operations isn't environmentalism, else they'd not be selling carbon credits to ICE manufacturers, incentivising them to avoid EV production.
  And it's not even just that "the good" was only to make money, it's that it's as a member of the landed gentry he had the opportunity to throw many things at the wall that failed before the Tesla takeover stuck; his 'intervention' is simply a VC success story by happenstance.
  Taking this at face value, is what he did with Tesla really laudable at all? It is a lucky byproduct of elitism.
  
  Add “born privileged, into wealth” to Nazi enabler.
  You’re right to critique his motivations.
  Privileged Nazi enabler & promoter L Musk has accomplished some genuinely impressive achievements in some of the worst ways for the wrong reasons
  How’s that?
  
  The Nazi enabler part being the bad side, you're saying we should to reconcile this with the good side. I'm saying the good side is actually just some good shit that happened. Attributing it to Elon would be a mistake because of all of the times he did the same thing with the same intent and it never amounted to anything. For the truly good person, their opportunities to do good things would have been well exhausted before the Tesla opportunity arose. If we're trying to balance the perception of how good we are it should be a function of the proportion of the things we do that are good vs. bad, not a function of how many things we have the means to try.
  
  Fair point!
  
  Tesla would not be where it is today without his intervention.
  Yeah, I might have actually bought one without his intervention.

143 comments