9mo ago

Court Bans Use of 'AI-Enhanced' Video Evidence Because That's Not How AI Works

gizmodo.com Court Bans Use of 'AI-Enhanced' Video Evidence Because That's Not How AI Works

This AI hype cycle has dramatically distorted society's views of what's possible with image upscalers.

A judge in Washington state has blocked video evidence that’s been “AI-enhanced” from being submitted in a triple murder trial. And that’s a good thing, given the fact that too many people seem to think applying an AI filter can give them access to secret visual data.

You're viewing a single thread.

235 comments

AI enhanced = made up.
- It's incredibly obvious when you call the current generation of AI by its full name, generative AI. It's creating data, that's what it's generating.
- Everything that is labeled "AI" is made up. It's all just statistically probable guessing, made by a machine that doesn't know what it is doing.
- Society = made up, so I'm not sure what your argument is.
  
  My argument is that a video camera doesn’t make up video, an ai does.
  
  video camera doesn’t make up video, an ai does.
  What's that even supposed to mean? Do you even know how a camera works? What about an AI?
  
  Yes, I do. Cameras work by detecting light using a charged coupled device or an active pixel sensor (CMOS). Cameras essentially take a series of pictures, which makes a video. They can have camera or lens artifacts (like rolling shutter illusion or lens flare) or compression artifacts (like DCT blocks) depending on how they save the video stream, but they don’t make up data.
  Generative AI video upscaling works by essentially guessing (generating) what would be there if the frame were larger. I’m using “guessing” colloquially, since it doesn’t have agency to make a guess. It uses a model that has been trained on real data. What it can’t do is show you what was actually there, just its best guess using its diffusion model. It is literally making up data. Like, that’s not an analogy, it actually is making up data.
  
  Ok, you clearly have no fucking idea what you're talking about. No, reading a few terms on Wikipedia doesn't count as "knowing".
  CMOS isn't the only transducer for cameras - in fact, no one would start the explanation there. Generative AI doesn't have to be based on diffusion. You're clearly just repeating words you've seen used elsewhere - you are the AI.
  
  Yes, I also mentioned CCDs. Charge Coupled Device is what that stands for. You can tell I didn’t look it up, because I originally called it a “charged coupled device” and not a “charge coupled device”. My bad, I should have checked Wikipedia.
  Can you point me to a generative AI that doesn’t make up data? GANs are still generative, and generative AIs make up data.

235 comments