1y ago

Lemmy probably feels like Reddit when it first started, all warm cuddly and friendly to newcomers eager to discuss and collaborate around central topics.

I joined reddit on the tailwind, so it was all echo chamber, we hate newcomers, gatekeeping, automod frenzy, too many rulebreakers, too many rules, etc I could be wrong, but thats what I imagine it used to be like.

You're viewing a single thread.

344 comments

It's already like that here, friend.
Lemmy might be friendlier on the surface but has a much stronger hivemind-y aspect to it where you agree with it or else.
- It’s already like that here, friend.
  Lemmy didn't take off until well into May 2023, despite being online and open source for over 4 years. The quantity of posts, communities, comments was very small for 4 years online.
  Then everyone flocked out of hate and anger of an API money matter with Reddit.Then crowds got hate-filled and angry when Threads was launched by Meta/Instagram/Facebook on July 5. And crowds became hate-filled and angry over Elon Musk rename of Twitter to X on July 23.
  Outside big growth in memes and shitposts, there haven't been big numbers of people flocking here out of organic goodness on organized topics. It has largely been a HiveMind of hate as a motivation to come here since May.
  Some good seeds have been planted since May, but the atmosphere of hate motivates change is pretty much Mob Mentality / reactionary.
  
  Your timeline of events is intriguing to see and makes sense to me, even if I had a different experience. Thanks for that.
- Definitely, you can also see that on certain communities, there are very strong opinions which don't allow for discussion.
  Say anything that goes against the grain and you will be shunned immediately.
  Also - not that that is always a bad thing but Lemmy is extremely left leaning and you just can't discuss certain topics here at all.
  (Guns are always bad / Cars should all be banned and traded for bicycles / traveling by plane is bad and you should feel horrible for destroying the environment..)
  What I enjoyed about early reddit was the tech/nerd focused community that did not try to push their political opinion into every thread.
  Basically the worst part of reddit is already here, just that the echo chambers are smaller for now.
  Honestly, I'm not sure how I feel about it.
  
  As someone who was on Reddit when it was young I am going to disagree with you here. Young Reddit was absolutely full of political ideology. It was a Ron Paul, legalize weed, atheist, soft anti feminist, cypher punk, USA style libertarian pool of ideology.
  All places have an ideology. We are all constantly swimming in ideology. It’s just when an ideology matches you (either you being molded by the ideology or you joining a place with a matching ideology) you don’t notice it. A fish only has to think about the medium it is in after it is pulled out of the water.
  
  It was a Ron Paul, legalize weed, atheist, soft anti feminist, cypher punk, USA style libertarian pool of ideology
  It's funny that I wasn't even on reddit back then but I remember that time and the kind of people who existed back then and they were definitely redditors.
  
  It's why Reddit Enhancement Suite was so valued on desktop for its filtering abilities and third party apps.
  And the longer people used the reddit the more likely they were to avoid going to /r/all and unsubscribe from most if not all default subreddits.
  Filtering is becoming just as important on the fediverse.
  
  How is Dorothy going to make it to Oz if you're hoarding all the damn strawmen?
  
  You really forgot about the Ron Paul hivemind that dominated early reddit huh.
- Indeed. Watch me attract downvotes. ahem
  Linux sucks, and Windows 11 is a great OS.
  
  I respectfully disagree with you.
  
  Very funny.
  
  🐧Must... DOWNVOTE... BLASPHEMY!!! /s
- I do like to debate. I try not to use the downvote button if someone has caught my interest enough to engage.
  
  I, too like to debate, and I do invite people to disagree with me if they can discuss in good faith. Easier to do in some communities than others.

344 comments