2mo ago

Tankies love Russian imperialism

You're viewing a single thread.

21 comments

What do tankies think of all the millions of citizens Russia killed in the ussr existance?
- Never happened, also it was just a few thousand, also they were kulaks and Ukrainians did it anyway. But also never happened, western propaganda. And what about NATO bombing Belgrade?!?!?!?!
- The same you feel when I ask about the millions killed yearly due to imperialism & capitalist overreach.
  
  It's not the same as all. I don't support any killings. But you, you have just now with your comment, tried to excuse all the violence and terror and suffering and death caused by ussr, by saying: the other side does it too. Thats seriously messed up. What kind of a person thinks like that. Despicable.
  
  I don't support any killings.
  Clearly you do. You support a world order that can only survive on exploitation of the global south and developing world. So yes. You do.
  You can pretend all you want. But you benefit from those killings you don't speak out against. That is tacit support.
  We can and should do everything we can to minimize suffering. You want to bury your head in the sand about the killing and suffering needed to support your lifestyle.
  
  Is Russia communist? Also is Russian annexation not Imperialist? Just seems hypocritical is all. We know imperial capitalism is fucked up and we protest it regularly.
  
  Modern Russia is an imperialist shit hole. The question I was asked was about the Soviet.
  
  Oh my bad. I thought you were talking about modern death tolls. I, wrongly, assume most of your .ml compatriots are uncritical Russian chauvinists. Sorry.
  
  Imperialism is only when the people idont like do it.
  
  Really? You accept that they happened, they are bad, and we should work towards a better society where that doesn't happen regardless of what coat of paint the government puts over their actions?
  
  That's the rub,
  You think government is inherently bad. I think they, and us by reflection are a product of their material conditions. Governments are a reflection of a people's relationship with material. IE - America says "Greed is Good" Ergo we get the corporate profits over people shitfest we have now. The first step towards breaking that hold is education and organization at a community level. So that is where I focus.
  I could get into a big lecture/discussion about Dialectical Materialism, the conditions requiring a vanguard, how that vanguard should be defined ect. ect. ect, how we as a people work to stop capitalist vampirism and "corporatism" (capitalism in a trench coat) - but I don't think that would help.
  Alternatively, I could pull the typical Tankie "Read theory" at this point (and I do think that is what is needed for us to continue this conversation, but I admit it's a copout that doesn't really give you a good starting point. Really though the first 2 pages of the manifesto would give you the gist of what I'm trying to say here.)
  So, where do we go from here? - If you have a suggestion, I would be happy to talk more.

21 comments