8mo ago

Pronouns

You're viewing part of a thread.

Show Context

478 comments

You could use a similar argument to stop literally any innovation. Things don't have to be an issue to be able to be improved.
- Language isn't about innovation unless it is an artificial language. People don't choose their words based on what is innovative.
  
  Are we not intelligent enough to make language whatever we want it to be? We actually do that all the time with political correctness and ungendering words like policeman.
  
  "We" are not under any obligation to make language whatever you want it to be.
  Again, most people have no problem with the singular 'they.' You do. Why should they change to accommodate you?
  
  I'm not obligating anything or asking for any accommodation. I'm trying to make an argument for a better system than what we currently have, whereas you just seem to be saying 'change is stupid'.
  
  No, I'm saying you can't force people to change their language if they don't want to no matter how much better you personally think it would be some other way. You can ask, but I don't know why anyone would agree in this case.
  
  Dude, we're probably the only 2 people on earth who are going to see this conversation, how am I trying to force anything? The responses you've given have made you seem like a very close minded person. If you don't agree with what I'm saying that's fine, but if you're going to engage in a debate then please address the things I'm actually saying. Otherwise I'm just going to stop responding.
  
  Cool, I wasn't talking about this conversation and I was addressing what you were actually saying, so I'm guessing you'll have no problem continuing to respond.

478 comments