Victory? [elder cactus]

https://www.eldercactus.com/

You're viewing a single thread.

238 comments

Free will also isn't real, but I don't go around to people I know and care about trying to collapse their entire world view around it. Sometimes it's better if people believe in fundamentally incorrect things that don't impact others.
Edit: here's a crazy idea, if you think I'm wrong...that's ok. Just leave me be? Maybe? Isn't that the point of my entire initial comment. Lol.
- Why did you write this comment?
  
  Because he wanted someone to ask, "What do you mean free will isn't real?!?!?"
  
  It was relevant to this discussion as I'm saying I similarly wouldn't bring this truth up with someone like my mother or similar as shown in the original post.
  My goal is not to convince anyone who feels differently, I just felt others could relate to my example. I will not provide any explanation unless specifically asked as my goal here is not to force my knowledge onto someone who doesn't want it.
  
  I think he's trying to refute your claim that your will isn't free. I.e. you made that comment of your own free will. Not literally asking why you made the comment.
  
  I do not believe I had free will to make or not the comment. And this seems upsetting to many. So I suggest they just keep their world view if it benefits them.
- If everything is predestined, whatever you choose is your destiny. Which means you get to choose your destiny. Even if the decision is already determined, your decision process is a part of that and whatever you decide is what becomes the future (or present). Predetermination is irrelevant unless it can be seen beforehand, but if it could, that knowledge could be acted on to change it. So either you can see the future and change it, or you can't so there's no functional difference between it being indeterminate.
  
  I agree entirely with your comment and I experience the illusion of free will. I just recognize it's an illusion.
- If you define "free will" as individual processing of input based on your genetic makeup and past experiences/memories and circumstances, with some inherent randomness. Then i guess free will is real.
  
  God damn quantum mechanics is like a "get out of determinism” card.
  
  Randomness is the exact opposite of what people usually mean by freedom, though, isn't it?
  
  Lol, thank you.
  
  But it's true. Our ~~neurons~~ axons are as small as can be, hence they sometimes misfire. Our brain works on that
  
  Nah, that's compatibilism. My favorite use of "that's bullshit but I believe it"
  
  Lol no it's not. This is the dumbest argument of them all.
  
  That there was a joke. What argument do you think I was making?
  
  Misread your comment. My mistake. Missed the sarcasm.

238 comments