1y ago

how to block meta from mastodon

https://mastodon.moule.world/@MOULE/110586193055950459

You're viewing a single thread.

523 comments

Bear in mind that this blocks you from seeing Threads posts on your profile. Unless you private your profile, this changes nothing as far as what they're able to see/pull from your account. Their official documentation states that the block only prevents users from seeing or retrieving content from those servers. You'd probably have to be performing some DNS-level filtering on incoming requests or web firewalling from the host level to prevent their incoming requests.
- Sure hope they get defederated at least.
  
  That's just the "block" function from the moderation section of Mastodon. Again, this won't prevent them from accessing your profile. It only stops people on your instance from being able to see anything from that domain. The only way to stop them from getting access to anything posted to your profile is by going private.
  If I can dig up the now closed Issue on Mastodon's GitHub, I'll post it in an edit. Main devs confirmed this is how blocking servers and "federation" is designed to operate.
  
  Maybe that's something that could be remedied somehow? One bad actor making space on the Fediverse and using it to data harvest from everything else, or at least just all the users profile info on it even if defederated sounds like a side effect with mixed implications.
  
  Well, you can't really stop anyone from just scraping your profile if it is public, through crawlers and whatnot. However, that brings me to a question - how is gdpr handled in the Fediverse? If any server just gets your data by design, wouldnt you have to give consent to every single entity hosting a server? I don't see how something like that can be done, is it just in a Grey zone right now, or was that somehow solved?
  Or rather, and this is just as speculation given my limited knowledge, wouldnt the owner of the server you signed up for be responsible, because it's his server giving away your data?
  
  In the issue, they likened it to someone going to a profile in a private tab. As long as it's public, it's scrapable, and the only to stop it is to make it not public.
  
  Wait, if I understand it right, Mastodon can't defederated with an instance? As in, I don't want to provide my content for the instance?
  Lemmy can do that, right? Because if not, then the whole idea is just a goldmine of free content to milk for corporations, that they don't even have to pay for hosting. And I'm extremely against giving someone a way how to monetize my content under such circumstances. (Aside from the analog hole, you can't stop bots scraping it, but that's at least some effort they have to do...)
  
  What's to stop that corporation from using private browsing to scrape that content anyway? Sure they don't have as much of a way to identify and link their ad profiles to other users, but if it's pure content they're after, unless a home server is completely siloed from the rest of the world and aggressively defends against that kind of scraping activity, that can't be stopped. That's the argument the Mastodon devs made.
- Can't you get banned from Threads? What happens when someone posts content on a Fediverse server that isn't supposed to be allowed on Threads? Porn, for example.
  
  I assume so, yeah. That pins on Meta's moderation doing its job. I'm talking the other direction, though - Threads/Meta scraping your data from your Mastodon account.
- ffs.

523 comments