Breaking: Supreme Court Shoots Down Affirmative Action.
Breaking: Supreme Court Shoots Down Affirmative Action.
Affirmative Action has now ended in the United States.
You're viewing a single thread.
73 comments
-
Good, any law that gives anyone an advantage or disadvantage based on race seems short sighted to me.
-
Jumping into a thread on such an important issue and leaving a potentially inflammatory response strikes me as bad faith. Would you like to expand your comment?
-
Does using a spare tire to get to the tire store also seem short sighted to you?
-
Been on that spare for a long time, if we don't go without we may never replace the wheel anyway.
-
your wheelchair is old so I threw it away, you're welcome 😤
-
That’s a big departure from the spare tire analogy. The spare tire analogy is based on the principle that affirmative action should be a stepping stone that gets us to the place we want to be and then stops being needed. Whether we’ve gotten to that point or not isn’t a topic I want to get too weighed down on, but I think the point is that the goal is a world where we don’t need affirmative action.
But a wheelchair is (in general) a tool that compensates for a permanent problem. People who need wheelchairs need them forever. Are you arguing that’s what affirmative action is? Systemic racism can never be undone and affirmative action has to live on in perpetuity?
Not trying to get too bogged down in the analogy itself, but it seems you’ve got a fundamentally different view of the issue than the person you’re replying to.
-
the goal is a world where we don’t need affirmative action
Completely agreed. A lot is lost when you go in for a one line zinger, and I'm not going to write up a whole post replying to someone who didn't put the effort in the first place, especially when presenting an opinion that's easily interpreted as hostile towards minorities.
-
-
-
-
-
But that's not what it does.
-
73 comments