both pretty extreme
both pretty extreme
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/23485321
111 comments
-
Why do you engage in a conversation that you weren’t a part of, if you’re going to ignore the context of the conversation?
You asking me what did I mean by social groups when I didn't mention social groups is "ignoring the context of the conversation". Just admit you were a lil bit drunk and took me for the wrong person.
-
I think it's fair to assume that you were the one who wrote "social groups".
Even if you didn't yourself say that term: You accepted the terminology, so I'll ask you: how are landlords a "social group" that the "far left" wants to "exterminate".
-
How about we skip this step and you just tell us your definition of "social groups" and it will turn out that people "far right" want to "exterminate" are social groups, but people "far left" want to "exterminate" aren't social groups (and aren't really fully fledged humans, if you ask me (dehumanizing you enemies is important)).
-
I'm actually more opposed to the term "exterminate". The far left would actually rather "expropriate" that certain "social group".
To "exterminate a social group" means genocide done by the exterminators. To expropriate the wealthy class usually means that the to be expropriated class shoots first.
But you centrists usually can't tell the difference between violence and expropriation.
Edit: I've been looking through your comments. "I never said 'social groups'! uwu" my ass!
-
The far left would actually rather “expropriate” that certain “social group”.
Oh, but somehow they ended up exterminating that social group instead of expropriating. Given the experience of the 20th century.
To “exterminate a social group” means genocide done by the exterminators
Yep.
But you centrists usually can’t tell the difference between violence and expropriation.
I'm not a centrist. I'm right-wing. I'm so far right, that I consider nazis to be far left.
-
Oh, but somehow they ended up exterminating that social group instead of expropriating. Given the experience of the 20th century.
I'm not here to defend bourgeois revolutions. Explain how e.g. Nestor Makhno or the CNT/FAI "exterminated" the bourgeoisie.
I’m not a centrist. I’m right-wing. I’m so far right, that I consider nazis to be far left.
Yeah. I figured that you didn't have an internally consistent worldview.
-
I’m not here to defend bourgeois revolutions
Ah, so you're a communist with the real-communism-was-never-tried flavor. Ok then.
Explain how e.g. Nestor Makhno or the CNT/FAI “exterminated” the bourgeoisie.
What about him? He was bourgeoisie himself, participating in bourgeoisie revolution. He's irrelevant to the question.
Yeah. I figured that you didn’t have an internally consistent worldview.
Where's the inconsistency?
-
Ah, so you’re a communist with the real-communism-was-never-tried flavor. Ok then.
Your ignorance amuses me.
What about him? He was bourgeoisie himself, participating in bourgeoisie revolution.
Tell me you just did a quick google without telling me...
And the CNT/FAI?
Where’s the inconsistency?
In your worldview. You said yourself that you think nazis are left-wing.
-
Tell me you just did a quick google without telling me
Tell me you did a quick Google without telling me
And the CNT/FAI?
Dunno wtf this is, but I bet another bunch of bourgeoisie
You said yourself that you think nazis are left-wing.
You said my worldview is internally inconsistent. Nazis being left wing contradicts some of my other beliefs? Or is it that my worldview contradicts your cringe communist worldview? Well, fuck your worldview then. You're wrong and I'm right.
-
Tell me you did a quick Google without telling me
Lol, afraid to admit that you have no idea who Nestor Makhno was?
Dunno wtf this is, but I bet another bunch of bourgeoisie
I thought that they "exterminated" the bourgeoisie, get your story straight. Also: shouldn't you be in favour of exterminating the boprgeoisie, if you "despise democracy"?
You said my worldview is internally inconsistent. Nazis being left wing contradicts some of my other beliefs?
I guess you've got me there: your worldview might be internally consistent. It just probably clashes with fundamental truths of reality. I've yet to meet someone who claims that the Nazis were "far left" where that's not the case.
You’re wrong and I’m right.
Prove it. Make an argument.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
111 comments